| 2025 |
| Isiah Alexander - Framington State University (d3) |
| 2024 |
| Reggie Washington- Delaware Valley University (d3) |
| Ryan Blakey- Keene State University (d3) |
| Nhine Wills- Middle Georgia State University (d3) |
| 2023 |
| Rasheed Cooley- Stevenson University (d3) |
| Diallo Barry- Fitchburg State University (d3) |
| Justin Minor- University of District of Columbia (d3) |
| 2022 |
| Devin Thomas- Wilson College (d3) |
| Armon Williams- Washington Adventist University (d3) |
| Shawn Barclay- York College (d3) |
| 2020 |
| Lelan Eackles- Bowie State University (d3) |
| Warrick Goowin- Wilson College (d3) |
